DID ISRAEL "STEAL" THE so-called "PALESTINIAN'S" LAND?
"From the RIVER to the SEA" of Lies: The AYN RAND INSTITUTE debunks the "Palestinian" advocate's negationist, revisionist, historical inventions.
WIKIPEDIA: Historical negationism,[2][3] also called historical denialism, is falsification[4][5] or distortion of the historical record.
LAND FOR PEACE AND THE TWO STATE SOLUTION ARE STRAW MAN-HOLLOW MAN PLOYS THAT CANNOT POSSIBLY BE REALIZED.
BOTH IDEAS ARE BASED ON NEGATIONISM.
One reason is that a "Palestinian” state called Jordan already exists.
With Israel, the two constitute two states established more or less at the same time, one for Palestinian Jews, the other for Palestinian Arabs.
If the West Bank (which is Israel proper under the mandate) were to become a state (which is impossible for it depends on almost everything for its infrastructure on Israel), we’d have three states. And if Gaza were incorporated into a state, we would be dealing with four. Why not five while we’re at it?
The narrative is a straw man ploy. In the video next you will learn why that is so.
The first is the fake map you see reprinted everywhere. But it is, fake, totally dishonest, designed to fool people by decontextualizing history and physical reality.
The map above many of you have seen and regurgitated as “fact” across the global media is fiction in the same sense The Protocols of the Elders of Zion was a fairy tale. The irony is, both likely came from the very same source on Lubyanka Square, Moscow.
There are videos, sources, and commentators who have attempted to explain the history of the region. The map above has been republished by major publications for decades, illustrating a political ideal to which some have innocently subscribed. It fails however to illustrate historical reality, for what it posits has never happened.
This land was governed by the Ottoman Empire for 150 years. Turkic tribes from the Russian and Persian steppes are not Arabs, but tribal people just like the Slavs and the Magyars (Hungarians).
None of them are native to the Levant, the history is easy to understand:
The Romans “stole “ the land from the Jews ca. 2100 years ago (give or take a minute or two). A series of subsequent invasions by various tribal people “stole” the land from the previous invaders. Almost last of these were the Ottomans. After WW I the Brits “stole” the land from the Ottomans. The Ottomans are Turks, not Arabs, whose empire collapsed of its own backwardness.
In 1948 those impertinent Jews “stole” their own land back.
The Jews “stole” it not from the Ottomans, or Muslims of any sort, but from the Brits who were neither Muslims, nor Jewish, nor the native people of the land.
In a not-so secret deal for much needed oil in a world going industrial, between the Brits, Saudi Arabia, and the then-trans-Jordan monarch, the Brits and the cousin of the Saudi royals expropriated 77% of the mandated Palestinian-Jewish homeland meant to be given to Palestinian Jews.
Before 1947 Jordan didn’t exist, except in the wet dreams of a Saudi goat herder named Abdullah, the first self-appointed “king” of Jordan. There was no national movement similar to Zionism to create an Arab state in the Palestinian Territory. That nation was merely a gift to a fellow who could guarantee the unimpeded flow of oil to the West, along with roasted lamb chops for the night’s dinner.
That is the history in a nutshell of Palestine and a Palestinian people, who right now occupy 77% of the Palestinian territories that was never a nation. The so-called “Palestinian’s” and HAMAS’ aim is about taking, er, “stealing” the rest - the 23% that constitutes Israel. It is because 55 Muslim states are not enough, and one Jewish state is too much.
The international Brit journal MAIL-Online brings us up to current events, using contemporaneous newsreels to the 2023 invasion from Gaza. The video also illustrates HAMAS’ history, aims, and alliances:
What kind of people call for the genocide of another?
The answer is, the kind who have no legitimacy of their own, a fictional people marinated in fictionalized history.
'From the River to the Sea': A Call to Genocide!
Hamas terror group's charter explicitly calls for Israel's destruction
DO THE SO-CALLED “PALESTINIAN” ARABS HAVE A LEGITIMATE CLAIM TO ISRAELI TERRITORY AFTER THEY HAD ALREADY RECEIVED 77% OF THE HISTORICAL PARTITION SEEN IN THE MAPS ABOVE?
WELL YES, IF YOU DELIBERATELY CHOSE TO IGNORE THE FOLLOWING THREE HISTORICAL CONSIDERATIONS:
A “Palestinian” state, country, nation, and “people,” have never existed in history. “Palestine” is a name the Romans concocted to subjugate and insult the first century Israelites who refused to take a knee, by conflating surrounding nomadic people, i.e. Bedouins, with Aegean people called Philistines: Israel’s historic enemy (refer to the David and Goliath fable.) The problem with the “Palestinian” Naqba fiction, as well as with the name, is that the Philistines were not “Palestinians”, but sailors, fishermen, and warriors from the Aegean islands.
In other words, The Philistines were Greeks.
The characteristics of nation-and-peoplehood require distinguishing features constituting their society. These incorporate a people’s unique history, cuisine, culture, language, literature, script, mythology and religion, historic artifacts and archeology - creativity and art displayed in the world’s museums - architecture, attire, accomplishments, currency and coin. The so-called “Palestinians” (for our purposes here solely referred to as Arab and not Jewish Palestinians), never had characteristics of people-and-nationhood. They are Arabs from everywhere. The Hebrews, or Israelites if you will, always had them. So did the French, Russians, Germans, Spanish, Irish, Brits, Italians, Greeks, Egyptians, Chinese, and Hungarians.
There is a caveat however: The Hebrews had acquired the characteristics of nation-and-peoplehood thousands of years before, arguably, but for the two named above: Egyptians and Chinese. The Israeli commonweal had come into existence millenia before any European nation called itself European - including the Romans.
No museum on the planet displays a single Arab “Palestinian” artifact not Hebraic, and not one “Palestinian” can name Palestine’s first monarch or its last.
MILITARY WIKI: ZUHEIR MOHSEN, CHIEF OF THE EL-SAQIA FACTION OF THE SYRIAN PLO:
The so-called Arab “Palestinians” not only failed to materialize through recorded history, but were demonstrably invented by the Soviet KGB in 1964-1967, when the Soviets exported revolution to Asia (Vietnam, Cambodia, Malaysia), Africa, and South and Central America (Cuba, Venezuela).
These facts were detailed and documented by the top-level KGB official assigned to Romania, Ion Mikhai Pocepa...and more decisively after Soviet Russia dissolved and the Mitrokhin Archives I & II were spirited to the West.
You can view The Mitrokhin Archives at the Churchill Archives Center, UK!
The historical “Palestinian”-NAZI nexus is 80 years-old and in force today - above is the first “Palestinian” leader, the Mufti of Jerusalem!
HAMAS and Hezbollah are both NAZI and Jihadi organizations united in a common cause calling for A Field of Dead Jews “FROM THE RIVER TO THE SEA.”
********
NEW YORK POST:
MEET THE TOP-LEVEL LEADERSHIP OF HAMAS WHO ILLUSTRATE THE HEROIC EXISTENCE THEY’VE LED TO GIVE JUSTIFICATION AND “LEGITIMACY” TO THE PALESTINIAN CAUSE - Click this link!
DISCOVER WHERE $11 BILLION IS BEING ENJOYED BY A GANG OF TERRORISTS. FOLLOW THE MONEY - TERROR IS, INDEED, BIG BUSINESS!
********
The Religion of Peace’s Isis-DAESH, al-Queda, and HAMAS, are cut from the same cloth, the same ideology and beliefs. They behead Christians and Jews alike for Allah, and attempt to steal land that belongs to others.
The only legitimacy the Palestinians have is that which they had bestowed on each other.
The Arab nations whining about the 400,000 displaced refugees they had self-inflicted on the world, expelled a million Jews in 1948.
THE WAR BETWEEN THE PALESTINIAN-HAMAS-HEZBOLLAH-ISIS NEXUS IS BETWEEN GOOD AND EVIL. THERE IS NO EQUIVALENCY BETWEEN THE ISRAELITE AND “PALESTINIAN” CAUSE FOR TOO MANY REASONS TO LIST HERE.
To answer the question that began this essay, no, the Jews did not steal anyone’s land. One cannot “steal” land that one has owned for thousands of years. Nor has Israel “occupied” another’s land for the same reason: because it isn’t another’s land.
In fact Arabs from everywhere, after 1964 called “Palestinians,” stole 77% of the territory from the Jews. Much of what they stole, and occupy, constitute ancient Israel, which extended from Sinai (today Egypt), to the Euphrates, Mesopotamia (today’s Iraq, and well into Jordan.)
The terror never had anything to do with “Palestinian Rights” for a people who never existed in referential reality, but mostly were imported labor that voluntarily arrived at the turn of the century to help build the nascent Zionist state. The Palestinians are Arabs from everywhere, as their early leaders had explicitly revealed, and not indigenous to the land to which they make a claim.
In other words, they are, even the Israeli citizens within Israel, squatters. Squatting on land not yours does not make it yours, even if you had squatted on it for 140 years.
THE TERROR IS BACKED BY GREED AND MONEY FOR BILLIONAIRES WILLING TO MURDER THEIR OWN PEOPLE TO MAKE MORE MONEY.
The conflict has little to do with a relatively few Arabs having been “evicted” in 1948 from less than 1% of the Mideast, and being treated today by the international powers as if they were the only people in history who were displaced. The conflict has everything to do with Jihad, conquest, and yes, land theft. The theft of Israelite territory.
As well as taking advantage of the European's ignorance of their own history.
The theft of the Holy Land is pertinent not just for the Jews who have continuously and legally occupied it, but for Christianity that also makes legitimate claim to the land’s history and legacy, to its Jewish Savior, and its own Jewish heritage.
—
—
© Andrew G. Benjamin is in finance, real estate and equities, a former advisor to New York City mayor‘s office (Subcommittee on Taxation, Finance and the Budget). Benjamin wrote extensively about politics, transnational and domestic, intelligence and military affairs, security and strategy, economic issues, Mideast, terrorism, technology and high end audio.
PLEASE SUPPORT MY WORK AND POST THESE ESSAYS TO TWITTER, INSTAGRAM, GETTR, MINDS, TRUTH, RUMBLE, FACEBOOK, GAB, AND OTHERS!
—
FURTHER READING: